RSS
Showing posts with label Rhimes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rhimes. Show all posts

THE SKED'S MIDSEASON RETURN: "Grey's Anatomy"



Even diminished from the powerhouse it once was, GREY'S ANATOMY is the foundation of ABC's drama schedule, and its return to the air after a nearly 2 month absence should lift the network's Thursday considerably.

WHERE WE LEFT OFF:  Things were grim when we last visited Seattle Grace.  Cristina (Sandra Oh) had, unknowingly, operated on Teddy (Kim Raver)'s husband--and presided over his tragic, unavoidable death on the table.  Avery (Jesse Williams) had carelessly left an object in a young mother's body that had shredded her heart.  (And while Teddy desperately tried to save the woman's life, the rest of the staff withheld the news of her husband's death from her.)  Meanwhile Meredith (Ellen Pompeo), having just learned that she and Derek (Patrick Dempsey) weren't going to be allowed to adopt the baby they'd been caring for, was caught with Karev (Justin Chambers) in a horrific accident in which the ambulance carrying them and the (other) baby they were trying to save was hit on a blind curve, overturning them and totaling the car that crashed into them.


WHERE WE ARE:  The 2012 premiere picked up just where the midseason finale had left off, and things didn't get markedly more cheerful.  The oldest daughter of the car crash family had to watch not just one but both of her parents die in front of her eyes at the hospital (in a rather too convenient plot turn, she had just turned 18 in the hours since the accident, and so was able to order life support turned off for her dad).  Various teams of regulars worked on the survivors while Meredith tried to comfort the girl.  While all this was going on, a blatant but irresistibly dramatic contrivance found Teddy insisting on having Cristina to assist her in trying to save the woman with the shredded heart--cheerfully enjoying their operating table camaraderie, oblivious to the other doctors watching the ghastly spectacle from the gallery, having no idea that her husband was dead and Cristina had performed the operation.  

Even eight years into its run, with many of its original characters gone and its ratings a memory of what they used to be, Grey's is still a powerfully slick piece of entertainment.  Shonda Rhimes' sense of pace and ability to alternate light and dark storylines is far more effective here than it's ever been on Private Practice, exemplified here by the episode's final, however implausible, happy ending for Meredith and Derek after the hell they'd gone through in the preceding hours.  The cast continues to perform at a very high level:  although Meredith Grey is still technically the show's center, Sandra Oh's Cristina has long been doing the heavy dramatic lifting on the series, and this episode gave her and Kim Raver a showcase, for much of which Oh had to make her miserably mixed emotions clear under a surgical mask, able to act with only her eyes. 

However downsized its ratings may be, Grey's sole dramatic competition on the ABC drama schedule is the new Once Upon A Time, which got off to a strong start but has been stung by its own hiatus and some questionable scheduling moves by the network.  Like ER in its time, Grey's should continue on its network's air for as long as economics permit.

  • Digg
  • Del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • RSS

THE SKED'S MIDSEASON RETURN: "Private Practice"



Thursday night brought a mother lode of returning serialized dramas to broadcast TV, with both ABC and CW returning to duty.  Let's start by looking at ABC's 10PM PRIVATE PRACTICE, airing a fresh episode for the first time since a 2-hour special on November 17.

WHERE WE LEFT OFF:  As usual, there was all manner of trouble for the Santa Monica doctors.  Pete and Violet (Tim Daly and Amy Brenneman) were in the midst of a marital break-up; Amelia (Caterina Scorsone) had just emerged from a brutalizing bout with drug addiction and rehab, which included her breaking the heart of Sheldon (Brian Benben); Cooper (Paul Adelstein) had just discovered that he had a son with a one-night stand that he never knew about, somewhat to his wife Charlotte (KaDee Strickland)'s chagrin,;and Addison (Kate Walsh)'s continued determination to have a baby, now by adoption, was widening the cracks in her relationship with Sam (Taye Diggs).


WHERE WE ARE:  Private Practice has always been the weak sister to Grey's Anatomy, which of course is also produced by Shonda Rhimes.  The show lacks the narrative engine of the young doctors' ambition on Grey's, and it has a tendency to punch its metaphors, and the analogies between its patients' predicaments and those of their doctors, with a clumsy unsubtlety, as in this episode where the "rules" that govern a menage a trois trying to have a mutual baby (one woman's egg implanted in the other) fall apart, all too squarely echoing the rules Violet and Pete are trying to set in their separation, and the rules Cooper has to start enforcing with his new son--and in case the parallels weren't clear enough, we got a scene where all the doctors talked about how the menage's issues reminded them of their own.

Nevertheless, the show wisely didn't try to push the suds further than usual for its midseason debut, instead providing a fairly typical episode.  There was some big news, notably the episode-ending conclusion (or so it seems) of Addison and Sam, but mostly the developments were incremental.  Enough unspecified time had gone by since the last episode that Charlotte, the show's Bitch With A Heart Of Gold, was ready to let Amelia perform surgeries again, and Pete and Violet had officially broken up, but there was no special melodrama.

The trouble with Private Practice this season is the same one that afflicts many soaps when they get to their 5th season:  after a while, all the show can do is rotate its romantically-involved characters and relationships.  (Now that Addison and Sam are done, presumably the show will play the card of putting her with Benjamin Bratt's Jake, as has been inevitable since he joined the cast.)  Storylines like Cooper's newly-discovered son feel awfully close to shark-jumping, and how many times can Addison be bitterly disappointed in her drive to have a baby? (In this episode, a birth mother so admired and respected Addison that she gave her baby to a church couple instead.)   It would be best for all concerned if the series could start pointing its way to a definite finale, the way cable shows have increasingly been able to do--but Private Practice's rating, hovering around 2.5 in a fairly stable way that's down only about 10% from last season, as opposed to the 25% nosedive Grey has taken (although Grey's average rating is still almost a point higher than Practice's) makes it a valuable performer for the network, and likely to keep spinning its wheels for a while to come.

  • Digg
  • Del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • RSS

THE SKED PILOT REPORT: ABC'S "Scandal"


Disclaimer:  Network pilots now in circulation are not necessarily in the form that will air in the Fall.  Pilots are often reedited and rescored, and in some cases even recast or reshot.  So these critiques shouldn't be taken as full reviews, but rather as a guide to the general style and content of the new shows coming your way.

SCANDAL - Midseason on ABC:  Potential DVR Alert.

ABC's midseason drama SCANDAL is produced by Shonda Rhimes, which makes it a very slick piece of work indeed.  Better still, Rhimes wrote the script herself, so it has her distinctive monologue-in-the-midst-of-dialogue rhythms.  The show still needs work, but it has possibiilities.

For one thing, Scandal has an original premise.  Yes, a Shonda Rhimes series that's not about doctors (although the pilot does include one hospital scene; apparently she can't abide any show that doesn't include at least one person on an IV).   It concerns a group of lawyers in Washington DC under the direction of former Presidential aide Olivia Pope (Kerry Washington), who--they are at great pains to tell us--aren't a law firm but a crisis management outfit.  They handle high-profile clients--ambassadors, politicians, etc--who need their sensitive problems disposed of as quietly as possible.


Perhaps unwisely, the main plot of the pilot episode concerns a decorated soldier accused of murder--unwise, because even though the show desperately wants us to know it's not going to be a law series, the storyline feels like it could have come from any of TV's legal franchises.  The B-story, about a woman who claims to have slept with the President, is much more effective.  Also, the pilot (directed by Paul McGuigan) spends too much time in Olivia's offices--the action starts to feel hermetically sealed.  It's unlikely ABC would foot the bill to shoot the series in DC, but this is a show that would benefit from some healthy location shooting.

We don't learn all that much about the supporting cast in the pilot.  Henry Ian Cusick--Desmond from Lost--is the firm's womanizer who's trying to settle down, heedless that investigator Darby Stanchfield has a crush on him; Katie Lowes is the new girl at the firm (the weakest character so far--she's made to weep and be told that Olivia doesn't approve of crying); Columbus Short is the slick litigator, and Guillermo Diaz the requisite hacker.  It appears that the President (Tony Goldwyn) will also appear regularly, and he's a real asset.  More than in Rhimes' medical ensembles, though, the center of Scandal is clearly Olivia, and her story--which I won't spoil here--is a good one that provides plenty of potential grist for future episodes.  The script overplays the certainty of her "gut," though, and needs to avoid too many scenes where she plays therapist for her colleagues.

Since Scandal is slated for midseason (presumably to run with Grey's or Desperate Housewives at some point), there's plenty of time to do some overhaul on the project.   The show already has a smart producer, a fairly original setting, some sharp writing and a strong lead, so there's reason to be hopeful that they'll figure out how to make the pieces work together smoothly.


  • Digg
  • Del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • RSS