Movie Box Review

Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers - Done & Checking in!
Although it's actually April now, I not only finished The Two Towers on time for the March readalong, but I even finished early. But, because of timing and I just generally feel like writing about books on Sundays, I'm writing my check in post in April. As through out the month, our The Two Towers readalong host Shelf Love has given us even more questions to accompany the experience of reading Book 4. Here's the we go!

1. The last half of The Two Towers covers fewer characters than the first half. For some, this makes Book 4 slower than the rest of the book; others love the intense focus on Frodo, Gollum, and Sam. Where do you stand on this question?

I loved this section of the book! At some point I realized that the second half of the book wasn't as long as the first and nowhere near as long as the Fellowship and this made me completely whiz through it. I liked the Sam, Frodo and Gollum focus, but I wish there was more Faramir!

2. If you’re a first-time reader (or even a rereader), what surprised you most about this half of the book?

It feels already like the story is wrapping up, which is so odd considering there is all of The Return of the King to get through. Also, I find it emotionally conflicting to sympathize in this section with Gollum over Sam. I want to cheer for Sam but sometimes he's not so nice, althought I know he's just looking out for Frodo.

3. Are there any specific moments that stand out as favorites or least favorites in this section?

Not so much. I read this one out and about a lot instead of at home so I didn't take as many notes (heh, there an admission for ya). A lot of the sections I could, as I've said previously, see and hear the film. In particular PO-TA-TOES! and Gollum/Smeagol chatter.

4. What are some themes or ideas in this book (or the trilogy as a whole so far) that stand out to you?

Choices & persistence. I admire persistence a lot, and I've noted that how much I like a character in this series feels very proportionate to how far they are willing to go or how quickly they are willing to give up. Also the idea of still attempting a task when you don't even know how to complete it, is fascinating. It's all about the journey!

5. And the obligatory movie question: Many LOTR readers take the biggest issue with Jackson’s treatment of this part of the trilogy than with any other? Did the changes bother you? Are there any ways in which you think the movie was more effective?

I'm going to rewatch the film today, but from memory I'd say there is a lot that was done in the film that shows a creative genius's interpretation of the book. Sure, it doesn't follow along step by step like Fellowship did, but the essence of the story stays intact and I found I understood more about the characters in the film. In particular the treatment of Gollum is so amazing, and it's an idea that if I heard about it I would say it would be too far fetched to be pulled off but somehow they did it. I'm really looking forward to revisiting the film, it's been a while since I've seen it!



2010 Book to Film Challenge Update

As with the mid month check in, I've decided to take the opportunity to write about some of the other books I've read recently and my progress on my 2010 Book to Film Challenge, where I'm now up to 6/20 films read! Yay! With the current pace I should finish all 20 by the end of the year with ease.

The Final Warning by James Patterson
Another book in the Maximum Ride Series, although I'm not entirely sure if it's Maximum Ride: Book 4 as it's also listed as The Protectors: Book 1. Bizarre. Anyhow, I continue to love the antics and adventures of this group of avian-human hybrids lead by their fearless leader Max, a teenage girl who kicks butt and takes names. I also really enjoy the casual writing style that feels free to used terms that may not necessarily be words, but certainly are things people say. It's also a great example of a series that gives you enough catch up information as a reminder from the last book, without dwelling/romanticizing the past. Thank you for that James Patterson, I appreciate it! The series are all quick, fun reads and I look forward to keep reading and seeing what happens next.

Uglies by Scott Westerfeld
Although I keep trying to find stand alone books, I keep getting sucked into series and this is a Book 1 of a 4 books series. It's teen fiction, scifi/dystopic, set in a world where at 16 people have surgery to turn from uglies to pretties. Interesting to continue to see the theme of beauty explored in teen fic (Beastly did this too), but Uglies reminded me that Tolkien aside I've almost exclusively been reading books by women's authors. Actually, both this and the Maximum Ride series are by male authors with female teen protagonists. Interesting. Anyway, Uglies was great - interesting world & ideas with characters & relationships that feel real & interesting. I did often feel like I could see where it was going, but I didn't always figure it out so it surprized me occasionally which I like. It reminded me of a "what if City of Ember and Logan's Run collided", but that's likely because I've not read too my near-future dystopic stuff. Looking forward to continuing the series, although I've got lots to get through in April so might be a while before I get to book 2.

Upcoming books for April 2010
The Lord of the Rings readalong continues with The Return of the King, this section of the readalong will be hosted by Just Add Books. I'm also diving into Emily Bronte's Wuthering Heights continuing with my 2010 book to film challenge & as a countdown to the film The Twilight Saga: Eclipse. Other possibilities include Perdido Street Station by China Miéville, The Lightning Thief by Rick Riordan and Cassandra Clare's City of Glass - the third in The Mortal Instruments Series. I'm sure there will be more. What are you reading in April?

Remember, if you use it, feel free to friend me GoodReads!

Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers - Done & Checking in!
Although it's actually April now, I not only finished The Two Towers on time for the March readalong, but I even finished early. But, because of timing and I just generally feel like writing about books on Sundays, I'm writing my check in post in April. As through out the month, our The Two Towers readalong host Shelf Love has given us even more questions to accompany the experience of reading Book 4. Here's the we go!

1. The last half of The Two Towers covers fewer characters than the first half. For some, this makes Book 4 slower than the rest of the book; others love the intense focus on Frodo, Gollum, and Sam. Where do you stand on this question?

I loved this section of the book! At some point I realized that the second half of the book wasn't as long as the first and nowhere near as long as the Fellowship and this made me completely whiz through it. I liked the Sam, Frodo and Gollum focus, but I wish there was more Faramir!

2. If you’re a first-time reader (or even a rereader), what surprised you most about this half of the book?

It feels already like the story is wrapping up, which is so odd considering there is all of The Return of the King to get through. Also, I find it emotionally conflicting to sympathize in this section with Gollum over Sam. I want to cheer for Sam but sometimes he's not so nice, althought I know he's just looking out for Frodo.

3. Are there any specific moments that stand out as favorites or least favorites in this section?

Not so much. I read this one out and about a lot instead of at home so I didn't take as many notes (heh, there an admission for ya). A lot of the sections I could, as I've said previously, see and hear the film. In particular PO-TA-TOES! and Gollum/Smeagol chatter.

4. What are some themes or ideas in this book (or the trilogy as a whole so far) that stand out to you?

Choices & persistence. I admire persistence a lot, and I've noted that how much I like a character in this series feels very proportionate to how far they are willing to go or how quickly they are willing to give up. Also the idea of still attempting a task when you don't even know how to complete it, is fascinating. It's all about the journey!

5. And the obligatory movie question: Many LOTR readers take the biggest issue with Jackson’s treatment of this part of the trilogy than with any other? Did the changes bother you? Are there any ways in which you think the movie was more effective?

I'm going to rewatch the film today, but from memory I'd say there is a lot that was done in the film that shows a creative genius's interpretation of the book. Sure, it doesn't follow along step by step like Fellowship did, but the essence of the story stays intact and I found I understood more about the characters in the film. In particular the treatment of Gollum is so amazing, and it's an idea that if I heard about it I would say it would be too far fetched to be pulled off but somehow they did it. I'm really looking forward to revisiting the film, it's been a while since I've seen it!



2010 Book to Film Challenge Update

As with the mid month check in, I've decided to take the opportunity to write about some of the other books I've read recently and my progress on my 2010 Book to Film Challenge, where I'm now up to 6/20 films read! Yay! With the current pace I should finish all 20 by the end of the year with ease.

The Final Warning by James Patterson
Another book in the Maximum Ride Series, although I'm not entirely sure if it's Maximum Ride: Book 4 as it's also listed as The Protectors: Book 1. Bizarre. Anyhow, I continue to love the antics and adventures of this group of avian-human hybrids lead by their fearless leader Max, a teenage girl who kicks butt and takes names. I also really enjoy the casual writing style that feels free to used terms that may not necessarily be words, but certainly are things people say. It's also a great example of a series that gives you enough catch up information as a reminder from the last book, without dwelling/romanticizing the past. Thank you for that James Patterson, I appreciate it! The series are all quick, fun reads and I look forward to keep reading and seeing what happens next.

Uglies by Scott Westerfeld
Although I keep trying to find stand alone books, I keep getting sucked into series and this is a Book 1 of a 4 books series. It's teen fiction, scifi/dystopic, set in a world where at 16 people have surgery to turn from uglies to pretties. Interesting to continue to see the theme of beauty explored in teen fic (Beastly did this too), but Uglies reminded me that Tolkien aside I've almost exclusively been reading books by women's authors. Actually, both this and the Maximum Ride series are by male authors with female teen protagonists. Interesting. Anyway, Uglies was great - interesting world & ideas with characters & relationships that feel real & interesting. I did often feel like I could see where it was going, but I didn't always figure it out so it surprized me occasionally which I like. It reminded me of a "what if City of Ember and Logan's Run collided", but that's likely because I've not read too my near-future dystopic stuff. Looking forward to continuing the series, although I've got lots to get through in April so might be a while before I get to book 2.

Upcoming books for April 2010
The Lord of the Rings readalong continues with The Return of the King, this section of the readalong will be hosted by Just Add Books. I'm also diving into Emily Bronte's Wuthering Heights continuing with my 2010 book to film challenge & as a countdown to the film The Twilight Saga: Eclipse. Other possibilities include Perdido Street Station by China Miéville, The Lightning Thief by Rick Riordan and Cassandra Clare's City of Glass - the third in The Mortal Instruments Series. I'm sure there will be more. What are you reading in April?

Remember, if you use it, feel free to friend me GoodReads!

What I've been reading...Amazing the consistent colour story in the book covers, eh?

Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers - Mid Month Check in!
I feel like I've been a little slacking in my reading of The Two Towers but thankfully our gracious readalong host Shelf Love has given us some questions to ponder as a MidMonth check in. This is totally serving as inspiration to keep on trucking through Middle Earth for me.

Mid Month Check in Questions!

1. Where are you in your reading? Are you finding it slow going or is it a quick read?

I've just started into Book Four, which is a little behind my plan but not so far behind that I think I can't catch up. In terms of the story, Gollum was just talking to himself.

2. If you’re a rereader, how does this reading compare to past readings? If you’re a first-time reader, how has The Two Towers met—or not met—your expectations? What has surprised you most in your reading?

I've only read this once before, and I really raced though it. So far I'd say it's not met my expectations. I'm still stuck by how familiar the world/creatures/ideas are to be from their being used in general fantasy out there over and over again, rather than from reading the book originally.

3. In Book 3, we visit lots of new places and meet lots of new characters. There’s Fangorn and the Ents, the riders of Rohan, Saruman at Isengard. Which are your favorites? Least favorites?

Highlights are anything in Rohan. Love Eomer, Eowyn and Theoden. I'm surprized I didn't like the Ents more (I still 'hear' Gimli's voice though from the film when Treebeard talks. Why they did that I'll never know.), I found Isengard section a little boring.

4. Have your opinions of the main characters from Fellowship changed at all in The Two Towers?

Opinions haven't changed so much but really starting to see some interesting character development. You really start to see the change in Frodo here. He starts getting a little miffy and short on patience, but it's nicely done being gradual and believeable. Pippin is starting to grow as well, although I'm sure I'm picking up on that a bit more 'knowing' that it happens, but I noticed it much more this time round. Zero development if feels from Legolas, Gimli and Sam. Aragon is getting a little kingly though, very interesting.

5. Are there any scenes that strike you as particularly memorable? Anything you could do without?

Not a scene per se, but I love this quote of Aragorn talking to Gimli when he's giving a little defeated attitude:

"There are some things that it is better to begin than to refuse, even though the end may be dark."

2 points for Aragorn.
Also, could do without a lot of the description. It's really descriptive.

6. And the obligatory movie question: If you’ve seen the movie, has it affected your perception of The Two Towers? If so, how?

The film is really affecting my reading. I hear the actors when the characters talk, and I'm impatient to see some of the characters that haven't shown up yet (namely Faramir). Also, I'm finding it a bit tough to get through it, so I admit knowing the film well makes me prone to speed reading over sections I'm less fond of (Helm's Deep, fighting in general) to keep up my reading pace.

2010 Book to Film Challenge Update

Although I've not finished reading The Two Towers yet, I've made progress on other titles on my 2010 Book to Film Challenge list:

New Moon by Stephenie Meyer (re-read)
By far my favourite book in the Twilight series, although sadly I didn't love the film. But, I will always love the book. I love the Bella/Jacob friendship and it is in this book that we really see that relationship grow. Why she loves Edward, I'll never understand. Anyhow, I re-read it in anticipation of the New Moon coming on DVD (March 20, 2010), which film wise I didn't enjoy anywhere near as much as Twilight, as well as in countdown to Eclipse which will be in the theatres June 30, 2010. Next up on that countdown is to read Wuthering Heights (because it's discussed a lot in Eclipse and I've never read it), then finally Eclipse.

Beastly by Alex Flinn
Another 'in anticipation of a film' read, this updated version of the story of Beauty and The Beast will be made into Beastly, set to release July 30, 2010. It's an interesting take on the story, from the guy/beast point of view. Alex Pettyfer is perfect casting as the pretty-boy-turned beast, and I'm curious how close the film will be to the book. From the picture released so far they've made changes with how 'the beast' looks so who knows what we will end up with. I didn't find the book as compelling, mostly as it's a tale of the beautiful/privileged having to deal with not being so and... well...I don't have much sympathy for that. Also, for an 'updated' version, I was suprized it didn't take the opportunity to update in more areas, specifically gender roles and witch stereotypes. But, now I'm even more curious about the film. So far there is a teaser trailer and featurette, which show a little to loittle and a little too much. What can I say, I'm the little bear kinda person - I want something *just* right. I look forward to seeing more.

Random Reading

The Awakening by Kelley Armstrong (Darkest Powers #2)
I read the first book in the Darkest Power series, The Summoning, earlier this year and I totally inhaled it. Interesting paranormal teen fiction and an interesting personal journey from the perspective of a female protagonist which I really enjoyed. The Awakening picks up literally where the first book stopped and again I inhaled this one reading it over 2 days and barely able to put it down. I really enjoy the characters here and am looking forward to seeing where their journey continues.

Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro
I picked up this one from hearing Kurt & Andrew talk about it over at the Cinecast when looking ahead to the films of 2010 and I didn't listen to much more than that as I could tell that it's one you really don't want to know what it's about, but rather to experience it as you read it. After reading it, I can say this really is the case. It was a nice jump to read some straight up regular fiction, although it took me a while to adjust to the writing style but it was really worth it. It was also nice to read something stand alone, because I'm in the middle of many series. Overall, it's a great book and one I'd highly recommend. The film adaptation is in the works according to Wikipedia the casting includes Carey Mulligan (An Education), Andrew Garfield (Boy A, The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus), Keira Knightly and Sally Hawkins (Happy-Go-Lucky). Wow, that casting is so perfect it almost makes me want to cry.

For fellow book lovers, feel free to friend me over at GoodReads!

That's what's been on my nightstand. What have you been reading?

What I've been reading...Amazing the consistent colour story in the book covers, eh?

Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers - Mid Month Check in!
I feel like I've been a little slacking in my reading of The Two Towers but thankfully our gracious readalong host Shelf Love has given us some questions to ponder as a MidMonth check in. This is totally serving as inspiration to keep on trucking through Middle Earth for me.

Mid Month Check in Questions!

1. Where are you in your reading? Are you finding it slow going or is it a quick read?

I've just started into Book Four, which is a little behind my plan but not so far behind that I think I can't catch up. In terms of the story, Gollum was just talking to himself.

2. If you’re a rereader, how does this reading compare to past readings? If you’re a first-time reader, how has The Two Towers met—or not met—your expectations? What has surprised you most in your reading?

I've only read this once before, and I really raced though it. So far I'd say it's not met my expectations. I'm still stuck by how familiar the world/creatures/ideas are to be from their being used in general fantasy out there over and over again, rather than from reading the book originally.

3. In Book 3, we visit lots of new places and meet lots of new characters. There’s Fangorn and the Ents, the riders of Rohan, Saruman at Isengard. Which are your favorites? Least favorites?

Highlights are anything in Rohan. Love Eomer, Eowyn and Theoden. I'm surprized I didn't like the Ents more (I still 'hear' Gimli's voice though from the film when Treebeard talks. Why they did that I'll never know.), I found Isengard section a little boring.

4. Have your opinions of the main characters from Fellowship changed at all in The Two Towers?

Opinions haven't changed so much but really starting to see some interesting character development. You really start to see the change in Frodo here. He starts getting a little miffy and short on patience, but it's nicely done being gradual and believeable. Pippin is starting to grow as well, although I'm sure I'm picking up on that a bit more 'knowing' that it happens, but I noticed it much more this time round. Zero development if feels from Legolas, Gimli and Sam. Aragon is getting a little kingly though, very interesting.

5. Are there any scenes that strike you as particularly memorable? Anything you could do without?

Not a scene per se, but I love this quote of Aragorn talking to Gimli when he's giving a little defeated attitude:

"There are some things that it is better to begin than to refuse, even though the end may be dark."

2 points for Aragorn.
Also, could do without a lot of the description. It's really descriptive.

6. And the obligatory movie question: If you’ve seen the movie, has it affected your perception of The Two Towers? If so, how?

The film is really affecting my reading. I hear the actors when the characters talk, and I'm impatient to see some of the characters that haven't shown up yet (namely Faramir). Also, I'm finding it a bit tough to get through it, so I admit knowing the film well makes me prone to speed reading over sections I'm less fond of (Helm's Deep, fighting in general) to keep up my reading pace.

2010 Book to Film Challenge Update

Although I've not finished reading The Two Towers yet, I've made progress on other titles on my 2010 Book to Film Challenge list:

New Moon by Stephenie Meyer (re-read)
By far my favourite book in the Twilight series, although sadly I didn't love the film. But, I will always love the book. I love the Bella/Jacob friendship and it is in this book that we really see that relationship grow. Why she loves Edward, I'll never understand. Anyhow, I re-read it in anticipation of the New Moon coming on DVD (March 20, 2010), which film wise I didn't enjoy anywhere near as much as Twilight, as well as in countdown to Eclipse which will be in the theatres June 30, 2010. Next up on that countdown is to read Wuthering Heights (because it's discussed a lot in Eclipse and I've never read it), then finally Eclipse.

Beastly by Alex Flinn
Another 'in anticipation of a film' read, this updated version of the story of Beauty and The Beast will be made into Beastly, set to release July 30, 2010. It's an interesting take on the story, from the guy/beast point of view. Alex Pettyfer is perfect casting as the pretty-boy-turned beast, and I'm curious how close the film will be to the book. From the picture released so far they've made changes with how 'the beast' looks so who knows what we will end up with. I didn't find the book as compelling, mostly as it's a tale of the beautiful/privileged having to deal with not being so and... well...I don't have much sympathy for that. Also, for an 'updated' version, I was suprized it didn't take the opportunity to update in more areas, specifically gender roles and witch stereotypes. But, now I'm even more curious about the film. So far there is a teaser trailer and featurette, which show a little to loittle and a little too much. What can I say, I'm the little bear kinda person - I want something *just* right. I look forward to seeing more.

Random Reading

The Awakening by Kelley Armstrong (Darkest Powers #2)
I read the first book in the Darkest Power series, The Summoning, earlier this year and I totally inhaled it. Interesting paranormal teen fiction and an interesting personal journey from the perspective of a female protagonist which I really enjoyed. The Awakening picks up literally where the first book stopped and again I inhaled this one reading it over 2 days and barely able to put it down. I really enjoy the characters here and am looking forward to seeing where their journey continues.

Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro
I picked up this one from hearing Kurt & Andrew talk about it over at the Cinecast when looking ahead to the films of 2010 and I didn't listen to much more than that as I could tell that it's one you really don't want to know what it's about, but rather to experience it as you read it. After reading it, I can say this really is the case. It was a nice jump to read some straight up regular fiction, although it took me a while to adjust to the writing style but it was really worth it. It was also nice to read something stand alone, because I'm in the middle of many series. Overall, it's a great book and one I'd highly recommend. The film adaptation is in the works according to Wikipedia the casting includes Carey Mulligan (An Education), Andrew Garfield (Boy A, The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus), Keira Knightly and Sally Hawkins (Happy-Go-Lucky). Wow, that casting is so perfect it almost makes me want to cry.

For fellow book lovers, feel free to friend me over at GoodReads!

That's what's been on my nightstand. What have you been reading?

Last day of the month always feels like a time to 'check in'. Considering I'm playing along with the The Lord of the Rings readalong where February is the Fellowship of the Ring month, I'm feeling like it should be reading check in time considering I've set myself some lofty goals for 2010 with the Book to Film Challenge. I'll get to other books I've read this month but first up, let's see how The Fellowship went.

Thankfully, the Literary Omnivore who is hosting fellowship month has provided us yet again with questions to ponder and explore regarding the book.

As opposed to my spoiler-free film reviews, this post will discuss content of the book The Fellowship of the Ring. Please read only if you've read the book!

1. Since we’re dealing with a third of a novel, instead of the first novel in a series, do you find anything different?

I actually didn't know that. Learning happens all the time.

2. Do Books One and Two have significant differences to you?

Not really, I had to go look up and see what the transition was between the two books. Both start with meetings and end at water, for some random comparisons.

3. Who’s your favourite character so far into the novel?

Oh, naming names feels so wrong! With the fellowship, I found it very hard to separate the book from the film. I see the actors and hear their voices, especially with Gandalf, Galadriel and Boromir. I don't think I have one favourite character yet, although it might shape up to be Merry in the long run out of the people we've been introduced to so far. But, for this book I really enjoyed Boromir way more than expected. I love Boromir's stubbornness and strong belief and expression of what he thinks they should do - especially when everyone else is being so freaking indecisive. One of my biggest realizations was finding out that I'm not a big fan of (hides) Aragon. But! This is a *huge* relief, because I didn't love him in the film either - and now I can see it's really the character I don't love, as opposed to the casting or performance.

4. What surprised you the most?

What a challenge it was to get through the book. Holy crap, this sucker is denser than .. something dense. I was really glad I planned out my reading strategy and stuck to my schedule of a chapter a day at least 5 times a week. Without my schedule, I'd not have made it through. I was also surprized at how close it is to the film, not only with what happens but in spirit. I see the film when I'm reading it. I was also surprized that some chapters felt like almost nothing happened. With the chapter titles being so descriptive and often relate to the biggest thing that happens in the chapter, this really killed the anticipation of what would happen. For this one it doesn't matter - I remember it pretty well, but for later I might have to avoid them a little. I very much prefer straight up numbered chapters.

5. What was your favourite scene?

Tie between the Hobbits meeting Strider in Bree and the Frodo/Boromir showdown.

Bonus Question - Favourite Quote

"Where there are many, all speeches become debate without end. But two together may perhaps find wisdom" - p.523, Boromir to Frodo

Overall, I'm thrilled I got through it and am looking forward to watching the film later tonight with a new eye. It looks like several challenge peeps are going to wait and do a rewatch of all the films in May. I can't wait though! I might watch all the extended versions in May, if I have a whole weekend free. With The Fellowship, even though it took me the whole month to get through it, I do feel like I raced though a bit, but I can also tell this is a book you can (and people do) read over and over again to continue to get more and more depth. Again, a big thank you to Literary Omnivore for hosting this month's section of the Readalong!

I'm really looking forward to reading The Two Towers because I know the story a lot less and if I remember right it's a bit less of a literal book to film translation. I also know there are some awesome character coming up and really looking forward to seeing them. Thank goodness March not only has 3 more days to it, but that the book is a little shorter! I need some breathing room! The Two Towers section of the readalong will be hosted by Shelf Love.

2010 Book to Film Challenge Update

Along with finishing The Fellowship of the Ring, I also knocked off 1 more book on my 2010 Book to Film Challenge list: Saving the World & Other Extreme Sports by James Patterson. It's the third in the Maximum Ride series and was another great, fun, fast read. This series is like my breather series, when I need something a bit lighter it's my go to. The chapters are super short and it's jammed backed with action. This puts me at 2/20 for books read for the challenge which is right on track. Woohoo!

Random Reading
Since we are on the bookshelf here, I thought I'd share what else I read this month with spoiler-free impressions.

Beggars and Choosers by Nancy Kress
I loved the first book in this trilogy called Beggars in Spain, and with Beggars and Choosers I gladly returned to the near future world created and visiting the characters and seeing how life as progressed. What I love about the series is that it's SciFi, and is totally drenched in the science but it's still completely accessible for those that aren't science minded. I highly recommended checking out Beggars in Spain for folks that like SciFi and if you like it keep going with the series. My tagline for it was "I've not read a book that intently since Ender's Game", which is saying a lot.

Midnight Sun (Draft) by Stephenie Meyers
I read this purely so it could be discussed with Marina over at Before the Dawn: A Twilight Podcast. Midnight Sun is a draft version of part of the book Twilight from Edward's perspective. I'm not and Edward fan, but after reading it I can say that after reading it I do 'understand' him more. I don't like him more, but I do understand him more. If you want to hear more on this, check out the Midnight Sun episode of the podcast here. It's pretty interesting because we are on different ends of the Edward spectrum. If you haven't read Midnight Sun, you can! It's available online here at Stephenie Meyer's site.

The Gryphon Project by Carrie Mac
This one was pretty interesting, and it was a bit of a relief to read what is (at least currently) a stand alone book. It treads the dystopic/utopic lines and kind of reminds me of what would happen is you followed a story about teenagers form a world like Fahrenheit 451. I did have a beef with it, as it's from the perspective of a girl but the focus is primarily on another character. This bugged me in terms of certain dynamics as well as personal identity and expression - even in a fiction, dystopic world. I do recognize it was likely used as a storytelling style, but I couldn't stop thinking about it.

If you are a fellow book lovers, I'm hooked up on GoodReads now and loving it. Feel free to add me as a friend!

Last day of the month always feels like a time to 'check in'. Considering I'm playing along with the The Lord of the Rings readalong where February is the Fellowship of the Ring month, I'm feeling like it should be reading check in time considering I've set myself some lofty goals for 2010 with the Book to Film Challenge. I'll get to other books I've read this month but first up, let's see how The Fellowship went.

Thankfully, the Literary Omnivore who is hosting fellowship month has provided us yet again with questions to ponder and explore regarding the book.

As opposed to my spoiler-free film reviews, this post will discuss content of the book The Fellowship of the Ring. Please read only if you've read the book!

1. Since we’re dealing with a third of a novel, instead of the first novel in a series, do you find anything different?

I actually didn't know that. Learning happens all the time.

2. Do Books One and Two have significant differences to you?

Not really, I had to go look up and see what the transition was between the two books. Both start with meetings and end at water, for some random comparisons.

3. Who’s your favourite character so far into the novel?

Oh, naming names feels so wrong! With the fellowship, I found it very hard to separate the book from the film. I see the actors and hear their voices, especially with Gandalf, Galadriel and Boromir. I don't think I have one favourite character yet, although it might shape up to be Merry in the long run out of the people we've been introduced to so far. But, for this book I really enjoyed Boromir way more than expected. I love Boromir's stubbornness and strong belief and expression of what he thinks they should do - especially when everyone else is being so freaking indecisive. One of my biggest realizations was finding out that I'm not a big fan of (hides) Aragon. But! This is a *huge* relief, because I didn't love him in the film either - and now I can see it's really the character I don't love, as opposed to the casting or performance.

4. What surprised you the most?

What a challenge it was to get through the book. Holy crap, this sucker is denser than .. something dense. I was really glad I planned out my reading strategy and stuck to my schedule of a chapter a day at least 5 times a week. Without my schedule, I'd not have made it through. I was also surprized at how close it is to the film, not only with what happens but in spirit. I see the film when I'm reading it. I was also surprized that some chapters felt like almost nothing happened. With the chapter titles being so descriptive and often relate to the biggest thing that happens in the chapter, this really killed the anticipation of what would happen. For this one it doesn't matter - I remember it pretty well, but for later I might have to avoid them a little. I very much prefer straight up numbered chapters.

5. What was your favourite scene?

Tie between the Hobbits meeting Strider in Bree and the Frodo/Boromir showdown.

Bonus Question - Favourite Quote

"Where there are many, all speeches become debate without end. But two together may perhaps find wisdom" - p.523, Boromir to Frodo

Overall, I'm thrilled I got through it and am looking forward to watching the film later tonight with a new eye. It looks like several challenge peeps are going to wait and do a rewatch of all the films in May. I can't wait though! I might watch all the extended versions in May, if I have a whole weekend free. With The Fellowship, even though it took me the whole month to get through it, I do feel like I raced though a bit, but I can also tell this is a book you can (and people do) read over and over again to continue to get more and more depth. Again, a big thank you to Literary Omnivore for hosting this month's section of the Readalong!

I'm really looking forward to reading The Two Towers because I know the story a lot less and if I remember right it's a bit less of a literal book to film translation. I also know there are some awesome character coming up and really looking forward to seeing them. Thank goodness March not only has 3 more days to it, but that the book is a little shorter! I need some breathing room! The Two Towers section of the readalong will be hosted by Shelf Love.

2010 Book to Film Challenge Update

Along with finishing The Fellowship of the Ring, I also knocked off 1 more book on my 2010 Book to Film Challenge list: Saving the World & Other Extreme Sports by James Patterson. It's the third in the Maximum Ride series and was another great, fun, fast read. This series is like my breather series, when I need something a bit lighter it's my go to. The chapters are super short and it's jammed backed with action. This puts me at 2/20 for books read for the challenge which is right on track. Woohoo!

Random Reading
Since we are on the bookshelf here, I thought I'd share what else I read this month with spoiler-free impressions.

Beggars and Choosers by Nancy Kress
I loved the first book in this trilogy called Beggars in Spain, and with Beggars and Choosers I gladly returned to the near future world created and visiting the characters and seeing how life as progressed. What I love about the series is that it's SciFi, and is totally drenched in the science but it's still completely accessible for those that aren't science minded. I highly recommended checking out Beggars in Spain for folks that like SciFi and if you like it keep going with the series. My tagline for it was "I've not read a book that intently since Ender's Game", which is saying a lot.

Midnight Sun (Draft) by Stephenie Meyers
I read this purely so it could be discussed with Marina over at Before the Dawn: A Twilight Podcast. Midnight Sun is a draft version of part of the book Twilight from Edward's perspective. I'm not and Edward fan, but after reading it I can say that after reading it I do 'understand' him more. I don't like him more, but I do understand him more. If you want to hear more on this, check out the Midnight Sun episode of the podcast here. It's pretty interesting because we are on different ends of the Edward spectrum. If you haven't read Midnight Sun, you can! It's available online here at Stephenie Meyer's site.

The Gryphon Project by Carrie Mac
This one was pretty interesting, and it was a bit of a relief to read what is (at least currently) a stand alone book. It treads the dystopic/utopic lines and kind of reminds me of what would happen is you followed a story about teenagers form a world like Fahrenheit 451. I did have a beef with it, as it's from the perspective of a girl but the focus is primarily on another character. This bugged me in terms of certain dynamics as well as personal identity and expression - even in a fiction, dystopic world. I do recognize it was likely used as a storytelling style, but I couldn't stop thinking about it.

If you are a fellow book lovers, I'm hooked up on GoodReads now and loving it. Feel free to add me as a friend!

It's over halfway though the month and I'm happy to say I'm around halfway through reading The Fellowship of the Ring for The Lord of the Rings readalong. I totally didn't take the Olympics into account, because once evening sets in I want to watch and cheer on the athletes, especially fellow Canadians! Sometimes I read and watch as some sports have downtime between the ... ah, insert sporty term .. like.. flights in skating? Anyhow, not the idea reading conditions but if it gets me keeping reading I'm happy!

I'm enjoying the book way more than the first time round, but I'll admit I get impatient during the sections where it isn't something in the film because I kind of get confused as to what is going on. But I can tell in my heart this is a book that I will end up re-reading again and again.

Our gracious readalong host, The Literary Omnivore has provided us with some questions to reflect on mid-challenge. Yay!

1. If you’ve been with us since the beginning, how do you feel about the narrator compared to the narrator in The Hobbit?

I jumped in with the Fellowship, so no real insight here. I have picked up on when they refer to events in The Hobbit, which I'd never noticed before. The Hobbit is on my to read list. I don't even think I own it!

2. How’s your pace going? Is it smooth sailing or have you found passages that are difficult to get through?

I'm clipping through at the pace set at about 1 chapter a day, and as mentioned above anything that isn't in the film I find harder to get through. Or, to be more truthful, I feel like I don't really need to read it with as much detail because how important could it be if it was cut from the film. Wow. That's a little rude of me!

3. If you’ve read this series before, is The Fellowship of the Ring, for the most part, as you remembered? If not, is it what you expected or something else?

There are really strange and small moments I remember from the first time and re-reading them now has been rather wild, like igniting a long forgotten memory. Quite fascinating.

4. Are you using any of the extra features- maps and indexes, for instance- in your book?

Not using any extra features, although I do glance at the maps occasionally. I don't normally do that with fantasy books as I find you can easily tell where the story is going but here I already know so it's fair game! I am taking notes, although I have no idea why - I don't usually do that with books but who knows, they may come in handy!

For fellow book people, I'm using Good Reads site now and loving it! You can find me at the Good Reads site as Movie Moxie. Feel free to friend me!

It's over halfway though the month and I'm happy to say I'm around halfway through reading The Fellowship of the Ring for The Lord of the Rings readalong. I totally didn't take the Olympics into account, because once evening sets in I want to watch and cheer on the athletes, especially fellow Canadians! Sometimes I read and watch as some sports have downtime between the ... ah, insert sporty term .. like.. flights in skating? Anyhow, not the idea reading conditions but if it gets me keeping reading I'm happy!

I'm enjoying the book way more than the first time round, but I'll admit I get impatient during the sections where it isn't something in the film because I kind of get confused as to what is going on. But I can tell in my heart this is a book that I will end up re-reading again and again.

Our gracious readalong host, The Literary Omnivore has provided us with some questions to reflect on mid-challenge. Yay!

1. If you’ve been with us since the beginning, how do you feel about the narrator compared to the narrator in The Hobbit?

I jumped in with the Fellowship, so no real insight here. I have picked up on when they refer to events in The Hobbit, which I'd never noticed before. The Hobbit is on my to read list. I don't even think I own it!

2. How’s your pace going? Is it smooth sailing or have you found passages that are difficult to get through?

I'm clipping through at the pace set at about 1 chapter a day, and as mentioned above anything that isn't in the film I find harder to get through. Or, to be more truthful, I feel like I don't really need to read it with as much detail because how important could it be if it was cut from the film. Wow. That's a little rude of me!

3. If you’ve read this series before, is The Fellowship of the Ring, for the most part, as you remembered? If not, is it what you expected or something else?

There are really strange and small moments I remember from the first time and re-reading them now has been rather wild, like igniting a long forgotten memory. Quite fascinating.

4. Are you using any of the extra features- maps and indexes, for instance- in your book?

Not using any extra features, although I do glance at the maps occasionally. I don't normally do that with fantasy books as I find you can easily tell where the story is going but here I already know so it's fair game! I am taking notes, although I have no idea why - I don't usually do that with books but who knows, they may come in handy!

For fellow book people, I'm using Good Reads site now and loving it! You can find me at the Good Reads site as Movie Moxie. Feel free to friend me!

Earlier this week I announced that I am embarking on new challenge: 2010 Book to Film Challenge. To get things started I'm re-visiting the Lord of the Rings trilogy and playing along in an online reading challenge over at Shelf Love, which started in January with The Hobbit which I missed but I'm going to jump in with The Fellowship of the Ring and read it now and throughout February.

The Fellowship of the Ring readalong section is being hosted by The Literary Omnivore who to kick things off has posed us with several questions to ponder and share with fellow readalongers:

1. When did you first hear of The Lord of the Rings?
2. Have you read The Fellowship of the Ring before?
3. What’s your plan of attack, now that we’re dealing with more “mature” literature?
4. Have you ever seen the movies? If so, do you think they’ll influence your reading? If not, well, why haven’t you seen them?

Here are my responses:

1. When did you first hear of The Lord of the Rings?

I don't really remember not knowing about Lord of the Rings, which I think is one of the things that happens when you are the youngest in a family who love fantasy. I remember my sister Jamie's copy of of the book which was HUGE and the cover fell off but she put on another one if I remember correctly.

2. Have you read The Fellowship of the Ring before?

Although this book was definitely easily within reach for most of my life, I didn't end up reading it until 2001 when the film came out. I actually read it so quickly, wanting to be done before I saw the film, that I raced through it over the Christmas holidays and missed several key moments.

3. What’s your plan of attack, now that we’re dealing with more “mature” literature?

With 22 chapters to get through this month, the plan of attack is to read a chapter a day at least 5 days a week and sneak in an extra 2 somewhere in there. I don't think that really answers the question, but that's still my plan!

4. Have you ever seen the movies? If so, do you think they’ll influence your reading? If not, well, why haven’t you seen them?

I've seen and loved all the movies and have fond memories of seeing them. The Fellowship is definitely my favourite and I watch it almost every holiday season. The characters are fantastic and I fall in love with them every single time I watch it. The amount of care and love that went into bringing the vision to the screen. I do think the film will influence my experience of reading the book, I can already feel that starting to happen.

Bonus Question - Thoughts so far on the book:

I'm only 2 chapters in, but I have a few thoughts already. One - I'm mortified that my copy is one big dust machine because it was stuck in a box for way to long instead of on the shelf! It's so sad and I'm allergic which is not started me off on the right foot. I know I also purchased and omnibus copy of the books but I think I donated it several moves ago. Sigh. Also, this sucker is dense. Lots and lots and lots of words to get through. Knowing the film so well is strange because entire sections I think "That is exactly like the movie!" and I see Ian Holm, Elijah Wood and Ian McKellan as Bilbo, Frodo and Gandalf while I'm reading and can hear lines from the film "ProudFEET!". It will be interesting to see how this progresses throughout reading, especially when it gets to the few casting choices I didn't wholeheartedly agree with. I also find I'm very quick to notice things in the book that aren't in the film (which isn't much so far) and have a constant comparison going on in my head as opposed to just reading it.

Thoughts for the journey ahead...

I need to really set time aside to read this, I though I'd do a chapter a night before going to sleep but sometimes I've actually fallen asleep trying to do this (oopsies!). The chapters are long and the text is pretty heavy and I want it to get the attention it deserves. Also, after reading it I'm planning on sitting down and watching the film at the end of the month, and likely reviewing it as well to add to the every growing list of film reviews.



That's me trying to stay awake while reading!

Earlier this week I announced that I am embarking on new challenge: 2010 Book to Film Challenge. To get things started I'm re-visiting the Lord of the Rings trilogy and playing along in an online reading challenge over at Shelf Love, which started in January with The Hobbit which I missed but I'm going to jump in with The Fellowship of the Ring and read it now and throughout February.

The Fellowship of the Ring readalong section is being hosted by The Literary Omnivore who to kick things off has posed us with several questions to ponder and share with fellow readalongers:

1. When did you first hear of The Lord of the Rings?
2. Have you read The Fellowship of the Ring before?
3. What’s your plan of attack, now that we’re dealing with more “mature” literature?
4. Have you ever seen the movies? If so, do you think they’ll influence your reading? If not, well, why haven’t you seen them?

Here are my responses:

1. When did you first hear of The Lord of the Rings?

I don't really remember not knowing about Lord of the Rings, which I think is one of the things that happens when you are the youngest in a family who love fantasy. I remember my sister Jamie's copy of of the book which was HUGE and the cover fell off but she put on another one if I remember correctly.

2. Have you read The Fellowship of the Ring before?

Although this book was definitely easily within reach for most of my life, I didn't end up reading it until 2001 when the film came out. I actually read it so quickly, wanting to be done before I saw the film, that I raced through it over the Christmas holidays and missed several key moments.

3. What’s your plan of attack, now that we’re dealing with more “mature” literature?

With 22 chapters to get through this month, the plan of attack is to read a chapter a day at least 5 days a week and sneak in an extra 2 somewhere in there. I don't think that really answers the question, but that's still my plan!

4. Have you ever seen the movies? If so, do you think they’ll influence your reading? If not, well, why haven’t you seen them?

I've seen and loved all the movies and have fond memories of seeing them. The Fellowship is definitely my favourite and I watch it almost every holiday season. The characters are fantastic and I fall in love with them every single time I watch it. The amount of care and love that went into bringing the vision to the screen. I do think the film will influence my experience of reading the book, I can already feel that starting to happen.

Bonus Question - Thoughts so far on the book:

I'm only 2 chapters in, but I have a few thoughts already. One - I'm mortified that my copy is one big dust machine because it was stuck in a box for way to long instead of on the shelf! It's so sad and I'm allergic which is not started me off on the right foot. I know I also purchased and omnibus copy of the books but I think I donated it several moves ago. Sigh. Also, this sucker is dense. Lots and lots and lots of words to get through. Knowing the film so well is strange because entire sections I think "That is exactly like the movie!" and I see Ian Holm, Elijah Wood and Ian McKellan as Bilbo, Frodo and Gandalf while I'm reading and can hear lines from the film "ProudFEET!". It will be interesting to see how this progresses throughout reading, especially when it gets to the few casting choices I didn't wholeheartedly agree with. I also find I'm very quick to notice things in the book that aren't in the film (which isn't much so far) and have a constant comparison going on in my head as opposed to just reading it.

Thoughts for the journey ahead...

I need to really set time aside to read this, I though I'd do a chapter a night before going to sleep but sometimes I've actually fallen asleep trying to do this (oopsies!). The chapters are long and the text is pretty heavy and I want it to get the attention it deserves. Also, after reading it I'm planning on sitting down and watching the film at the end of the month, and likely reviewing it as well to add to the every growing list of film reviews.



That's me trying to stay awake while reading!