Movie Box Review

Showtime is having a very good season.  Subscriptions are up, HOMELAND has, for the first time, put the network in HBO's orbit of prestige, and the reburbished Sunday night line-up of SHAMELESS, HOUSE OF LIES and CALIFORNICATION has burst out of the winter starting gate, with double-digit gains for the 2 returning shows (a remarkable 30% increase for Shameless) and very promising numbers for the new House of Lies (its 0.6 last Sunday in 18-49s was double the debut of HBO's Luck).

Consequently, and to no one's surprise, Showtime has renewed all 3 shows for next season, adding to a bench that includes the returning Dexter, Weeds, Nurse Jackie, The Big C and of course Homeland.  Showtime hasn't yet found its signature ratings-plus-acclaim smash Sopranos or Game of Thrones... but it's getting closer all the time.  

Previously... On HOUSE OF LIES:  Marty Kaan (Don Cheadle) and his "pod" of associate management consultants (Kristen Bell, Ben Schwartz, Josh Lawson) travel the country, putting out fires for their high-powered clients while enjoying their lack of principles.  

Episode 2:  The second episode, written by series creator Matthew Carnahan, suggests that House of Lies won't be putting much effort into continuing storylines.  The idea seems to be more of a procedural approach, with a crisis-of-the-week solved by the regular characters.  This week, the Pod went to Phoenix, where they brokered a deal between the local NBA owner and his estranged wife that was clearly inspired by the McCourts and Dodgers in LA.

The  "plot," as such, was undeveloped and not particularly engaging, just another opportunity for Marty to prove he's the smartest guy in the room.  What was more interesting was spending considerably more time with the other Pod members.  Doug (Lawson), despite his Harvard degree, proved himself a fumbler with the ladies, as evidenced by an extended cameo encounter with Cat Deeley as herself that ended embarrassingly for Doug.  Clyde (Schwartz) is the fast-talking, more aggressive hustler.  And Jeannie (Bell), also no winner romantically (in this episode, she thought an old college friend was pursuing her, when actually he was just a headhunter offering her a job), has an ambiguous relationship with Marty, who killed the new job offer and wanted her to know it, somewhat to her satisfaction.

Those are all decent threads to be picked up as the season progresses.  On the home front, it turned out Marty's hate sex with his ex-wife/competitor (Dawn Olivieri) wasn't a unique event, but something they seemingly do regularly.  And the storyline featuring Marty's ambivalently gendered son (Donis Leonard, Jr) continues to feel like a refugee episode from Glee.

House of Lies, with its constantly scheming protagonists, is a good stylistic match with Showtime's other Sunday shows Shameless and Californication.  Compared to them, it lacks emotional depth and, seemingly, much interest in having any.  It does have a sparkling cast, however--Ben Schwartz was particularly effective in this episode--and that, along with a certain verve, may keep it at least moderately entertaining.

Showtime had a very solid premiere Sunday for its winter series.  The night was highlighted by a fine debut for HOUSE OF LIES, the Don Cheadle management consultant comedy, which had over 1.03 million viewers in its initial broadcast (this is total viewers, not 18-49, which we won't have until tomorrow and which will be considerably lower).  That was slightly lower than the 1.08 million who tuned into the first airing of Homeland, but as Showtime was quick to note, Homeland had a higher Dexter lead-in, and more people watched the multiple airings of House of Lies in the course of its evening than they did Homeland's.  Those who like to parse numbers Talmudically might note that as the night wears on, half-hour repeats are more likely to be watched than one-hours, but we'll let Showtime have its statistical point. 

Even better for the network was the tremendous increase for SHAMELESS in its second-season premiere.  Its 1.58M viewers were a whopping 61% above the 1st season premiere in January 2011, and shows that the enjoyably irresponsible series has found a real following.  

On the downside, though, CALIFORNICATION didn't hold the House of Lies lead-in all that well, dropping about 25% of its audience and coming in about 11% below last year's premiere (which had the lower lead-in of the 2011 Shameless start).  

As is usually the case, we'll know more next week when the shows are done with their marketing boosts and prove how loyal an audience they're actually holding onto.  

Showtime took a major step forward this season with its gripping new drama series Homeland, a show worthy of being mentioned with anything on TV.  The network's new comedy HOUSE OF LIES, though, is considerably less of an event.

The setting may be the world of management consulting rather than show business, but based on its pilot, House of Lies is trying too hard to copy its hour-mate Californication.  Don Cheadle has the David Duchovny unprincipled-but-talented role, playing Marty Kaan; it's no accident that his last name is pronounced like "con," because Marty's consulting business is essentially a con game--he manipulates jargon and statistics to tell huge companies what they want to hear in a way they're not expecting, and rakes in their cash.  In the pilot, he finds a way to spin a Wall Street firm's desire to justify its huge bonuses despite the recession, so that they'll look socially conscious even as they're buying yachts.  Marty is cynical and more than a little soulless, but he's our hero because he also has a breezy sense of humor and great charm.  (And because he's played by Don Cheadle.)

Marty has a team (he calls it the "pod") of young colleagues:  Jeannie (Kristen Bell), who's lovely and who, inevitably, Marty wants to sleep with (for now, at least, they merely exchange flirtatious banter); Doug (Josh Lawson), who went to Harvard; and Clyde (Ben Schwartz), who didn't.  So far Marty is the only character with a back-story:  he lives with his retired shrink father (Glynn Turman) and his young son (Denis Leonard, Jr), who's experiencing gender issues (in the pilot, we know he's potentially gay because he wants to play Sandy in a school production of Grease and go shoe-shopping).  Marty's token bit of depth comes with the disclosure that his mother committed suicide, although at this point we don't know anything about the circumstances.  Meanwhile, the show features the ever-popular contrivance of Marty's ex-wife (Dawn Olivieri) also being his most ferocious competitor in the consulting trade, as well as a terrible mother, a pill-popper and Marty's sometime bed partner.

House of Lies was created by Matthew Carnahan (based on a novel by Martin Kihn), who was previously the creator of Skin, the similarly cynical show about tabloid journalism with Courtney Cox that stumbled through a couple of seasons on FX.  Carnahan's work here is glib and superficial in a way that's moderately entertaining, but so far not emotionally involving at all.  Unlike Californication, there are no bonds of believable friendship between the characters, and nothing to compare to the thread of doomed romance between Duchovny's character and Natascha McElhone's that has always given that show its center.  Carnahan's plotting in the pilot seems aimed more at finding spots for gratuitous pay cable sex (a strip club is a key location for the episode, and a key plot point requires 2 of the female characters to jump each others' bones within about 30 seconds of meeting) than anything else. which is another unwise attempt to ape Californication's free-wheeling softcore style.

The one thing House of Lies clearly has going for it is its cast.  Cheadle, of course, is one of the best character actors around, skilled at comedy and drama, and he's capable of holding audience affection no matter how much of a snake Marty is.  (One of the show's more effective gimmicks is letting Marty step out of scenes to explain the consulting business directly to viewers.)  It's a pleasure to see Kristen Bell back playing a character with sharp, witty dialogue after her disastrous attempts to become a movie star, while Ben Schwartz has been hysterical as Jean-Ralphio on Parks & Recreation, and is clearly capable of doing more than the pilot allows.   

House of Lies has plenty of potential.  It's a smooth piece of work (the pilot was directed by Stephen Hopkins), painless to watch, with likable leads and a decent premise.  What it needs, though, is something to be about other than its own dexterity.