NBC: A 20% drop from a series premiere isn't ordinarily anything shocking or particularly worrisome. But when you start with a 2.0 the way AWAKE did, that leaves you with a 1.6 in Week 2, and that makes Week 3, when the show will be facing fresh competition on both CBS and ABC for the first time, look like an oncoming train. (The show continues to be problematic creatively, too: see our Pilot + 1 Review.) Earlier in the evening, 30 ROCK had its last 8PM airing of the season (COMMUNITY arrives next week) and remained 0.1 above its season low with 1.4, while PARKS & RECREATION was comparatively robust at 1.9. THE OFFICE and UP ALL NIGHT (with what may have been its most insufferable episode yet--if the show would just own up to the contempt it feels for almost all human beings, it might be a lot better) were up 0.1 from last week.THE SKED THURSDAY NETWORK SCORECARD
NBC: A 20% drop from a series premiere isn't ordinarily anything shocking or particularly worrisome. But when you start with a 2.0 the way AWAKE did, that leaves you with a 1.6 in Week 2, and that makes Week 3, when the show will be facing fresh competition on both CBS and ABC for the first time, look like an oncoming train. (The show continues to be problematic creatively, too: see our Pilot + 1 Review.) Earlier in the evening, 30 ROCK had its last 8PM airing of the season (COMMUNITY arrives next week) and remained 0.1 above its season low with 1.4, while PARKS & RECREATION was comparatively robust at 1.9. THE OFFICE and UP ALL NIGHT (with what may have been its most insufferable episode yet--if the show would just own up to the contempt it feels for almost all human beings, it might be a lot better) were up 0.1 from last week.THE SKED'S THURSDAY NETWORK SCORECARD
NBC: In the universe of NBC these days, you take your glass-half-full where you can get it, and here it is: AWAKE won its time slot, it was up from its lead-in, it had the network's highest Thursday 10PM rating of the season, and despite its unusually convoluted premise, it lost relatively few viewers during the course of the hour. So there's that. Back on earth, though, Awake was for all intents and purposes NBC's last chance for a scripted break-out hit this season (whatever Smash is, it's not that), and marked yet another failure. It could only reach a 1.9 rating against repeats on the other networks, and fell considerably below even the season lows for new episodes of The Mentalist and Private Practice. (Even against a Mentalist repeat, its margin of victory was a mere 0.2.) So: on to next year! Meanwhile, the rest of the evening was dismal as well: none of the sitcoms were more than 0.2 above season lows, despite airing against repeats on 2 other networks. Creatively, it was also a down night: THE OFFICE neared the end of its Tallahassee arc with its weakest recent episode (the big gag was that Ed Helms' character was beaten up by a little girl), 30 ROCK was unable to match the conceptual brilliance of its last couple of entries and resorted to network television's one millionth Law & Order parody, and PARKS & RECREATION was unusually scattered. (Let's not even speak of UP ALL NIGHT.)THE SKED'S THURSDAY NETWORK SCORECARD
FOX: AMERICAN IDOL's 4.4 rating was its lowest since the show began as a summer series 10 years ago. That was down 14% from last week, 38% from the first hour of last year's parallel episode, and 43% from last season's Thursday average. The combined Wednesday/Thursday average for this week was more than 20% lower than NBC's rating for Monday's The Voice. Oh, I could go on. The question is what--if anything--can FOX do to reverse the trend? The show is locked into its format and judges, so look for some high-profile theme nights and other stunting. The network may also have to give Idol some of the valuable promo time that would otherwise have gone to launching shows like Touch. Meanwhile, THE FINDER was down to the rating it was getting before it had Idol as a lead-in, although considering that Idol was down 1.4 rating points from the lead-in it provided 2 weeks ago, Finder's 0.2 decline wasn't at all alarming.THE SKED'S THURSDAY NETWORK SCORECARD
NBC: The gradual season-long collapse of THE OFFICE continued last night, as the show's 2.5 hit not just a season low, but its lowest rating since Season 1 in 2005--i.e., the season that almost got it canceled. That was still by far the s network's highest number of the night. 30 ROCK was misleadingly up from last week, which was an aberration caused by a program description that resulted in DVRs not picking up the episode; last night's 1.6 was in line with the other episodes this season (and slightly below recent episodes of Parks & Recreation, which it replaced for the night). UP ALL NIGHT tied its Thursday low. Perhaps the most pathetic news of the evening was that the meager 1.5 earned by a repeat of the post-Super Bowl VOICE at 10PM still marked almost double the rating Prime Suspect and The Firm had been doing in that slot.THE SKED'S THURSDAY NETWORK SCORECARD
THE SKED'S THURSDAY NETWORK SCORECARD
CBS: Keeping in mind that the Thursday 8-9PM landscape will change drastically next week with the return of American Idol, CBS got everything it could have wished from the debut of ROB at 8:30PM. The show's 4.1 blew past the numbers that Rules of Engagement was doing in that slot (let alone How To Be A Gentleman), retained 80% of its BIG BANG THEORY lead-in, and boosted PERSON OF INTEREST at 9PM to its own season high of 3.2. THE MENTALIST was at a standard 2.7 at 10PM, good enough to win the hour. Last year, the CBS 8:30PM sitcom (S#





